By Craig Lazzara
Mea culpa: Roughly a month ago, I used a dispersion-correlation map to describe how index dynamics can illuminate market movements. In particular, I reported that since high dispersion seems to be a necessary condition for a bear market, and S&P 500 dispersion levels at the end of February were far below those prevailing in past declines, conditions at that time did not look like bear markets had historically looked. Since our analysis uses a 21-trading day lookback, I providentially noted that “in 21 more days we’ll have a completely new set of observations.”
21 days have now passed, and we have a completely new set of observations. Market dynamics have evolved with extraordinary speed, as any sentient observer knows. Exhibit 1 shows the decline in the S&P 500 since its February 19th high, plotted against comparable data from the 2007-09 financial crisis. The index declined 32% from its peak through the close of trading on March 20, 2020. The comparable loss of value during the financial crisis required a full year.
Exhibit 1. Current Decline vs. Financial Crisis
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices. Data from October 9, 2007 (blue) and February 19, 2020 (orange). Graph is provided for illustrative purposes. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Just as values deteriorated rapidly, dispersion and correlation shifted rapidly. Exhibit 2 plots 21-day trailing dispersion and correlation between February 19 and March 20. The movement toward higher dispersion and higher correlation – upward and to the right – is striking. Bear markets seem less dependent on correlation than on dispersion, and dispersion has increased dramatically. But what’s particularly striking is Wednesday’s elevated levels of correlation.
Exhibit 2. Evolution of Dispersion and Correlation Since the Market Peak
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices. Data from February 19, 2020 to March 20, 2020. Graph is provided for illustrative purposes.
This makes fundamental economic sense, of course, since correlation measures the degree to which the components of the index move together. A pandemic of still-unknown duration and severity can be expected to affect every business adversely. The degree of adversity will obviously vary across industries, with some (e.g., airlines and hotels) suffering more than others (which accounts for heightened dispersion). But almost all will move down, driving correlations higher.
Exhibit 3 makes it clear that this has happened to an unprecedented degree, as correlations within the S&P 500 reached record levels for the month ended March 20. Students of index dynamics will not be surprised: high volatility can be expected when both dispersion and correlation are elevated. It is hard, in fact, to find other months comparable to this one; Exhibit 3 highlights those closest to today in the upper right-hand side corner.
Exhibit 3. Dispersion and Correlation by Month
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices. Data from January 31, 1971 through March 20, 2020. Graph is provided for illustrative purposes only.
Exhibit 4 identifies each month in which dispersion was above average and correlation was elevated (above 0.45), and asks what happened in the aftermath of the market’s reaching those levels. There have been 11 such months since 1971; in every case, the market was higher a year later, with an average gain of 24%.
Exhibit 4. The Aftermath of High Volatility
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes only. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Past results legendarily do not predict future returns, and Wednesday’s correlation levels suggest that more spikes in volatility might lie ahead. But selling stocks in environments like the present has historically meant missing out on the recovery.
Editor’s Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.